Shy Guy Gelato — Crafted by a gelato maker who perfected his technique in Italy, these Sicilian-style scoops come in flavors such as fior di latte, honey-sea salt-Toblerone and creamy cantaloupe.
Other Finalists
- Island Homemade Ice Cream
- Lake Champlain Chocolates
- lu•lu
- Offbeat Creemee
